Issue Information
-
#002022
-
0 - None Assigned
-
Fixed
Issue Confirmations
-
Yes (0)No (0)
0
Originally posted by Megamaniac
http://www.eathena.w...er&showbug=2022
Throw kunai is a skill which has a wrong implementation of damage calculation.
The oficial description of the skill notes that is not increased by % increase damage cards such as hydra card or peco peco egg card.
http://irowiki.org/wiki/Throw_Kunai
Note that this skill is affected by +ATK cards such as Zipper Bear Card, but the emulator also applies damage increases with race modifier cards.
I am in the process of fully confirmate this bug, I am in the way of making a screenshot confirmation of the bug but I have some problems as long as I can't use my account in iRo (no more credit card (IMG:style_emoticons/default/tongue.gif)) and have to test it in a hole new one (free account, so the test will have a time deadline). BTW, I have already asked in the official irowiki forum and have confirmation from other players that can confirm that the damage of Throw Kunai is not affected by % cards:
http://forums.irowik...p;postcount=135
That's all the info I've got right now about this case. Right now I'm on the way to create the character to make the test, but I want to ask for some other people who are willing to help making the needed tests so the bug can be finally fixed.
Thanks in advance for the help.
http://www.eathena.w...er&showbug=2022
Throw kunai is a skill which has a wrong implementation of damage calculation.
The oficial description of the skill notes that is not increased by % increase damage cards such as hydra card or peco peco egg card.
http://irowiki.org/wiki/Throw_Kunai
QUOTE
* This skill's damage IS NOT affected by % damage cards.
* This skill's damage IS affected by +ATK cards.
* This is a RANGED attack even if you are standing 1 cell from the target.
* This skill's damage IS affected by +ATK cards.
* This is a RANGED attack even if you are standing 1 cell from the target.
Note that this skill is affected by +ATK cards such as Zipper Bear Card, but the emulator also applies damage increases with race modifier cards.
I am in the process of fully confirmate this bug, I am in the way of making a screenshot confirmation of the bug but I have some problems as long as I can't use my account in iRo (no more credit card (IMG:style_emoticons/default/tongue.gif)) and have to test it in a hole new one (free account, so the test will have a time deadline). BTW, I have already asked in the official irowiki forum and have confirmation from other players that can confirm that the damage of Throw Kunai is not affected by % cards:
http://forums.irowik...p;postcount=135
QUOTE
I can confirm that throw kunai is not affected by % increase cards such as race cards. However, cards that increase your attack (i.e. andre, zipper bear) , and even wearing an ice pick can increase your damage.
That's all the info I've got right now about this case. Right now I'm on the way to create the character to make the test, but I want to ask for some other people who are willing to help making the needed tests so the bug can be finally fixed.
Thanks in advance for the help.
I would like to ask if the Throw Kunai skill is correct in renewal: http://rathena.org/b...ge-is-very-low/
It seems that it is doing 100%x3 damage when it should be 300%x3...
Could someone confirm this on kRO?
It seems that it is doing 100%x3 damage when it should be 300%x3...
Could someone confirm this on kRO?
Edited by Zopokx, 12 June 2013 - 11:14 AM.
Up? I'm interested in how the damage is really working...
here is the formula
damage = (300 * (base damage+kunai atk) / 100) - total DEF
So, iRO wiki is wrong?
http://irowiki.org/classic/Throw_Kunai (pre-re) vs http://irowiki.org/wiki/Throw_Kunai (re)
300% vs 300% ATKx3 hits
Someone reports me that actually is impossible to get the damage shown in this image:
(This report is before the last RENEWAL update from malufett, but...)
http://irowiki.org/classic/Throw_Kunai (pre-re) vs http://irowiki.org/wiki/Throw_Kunai (re)
300% vs 300% ATKx3 hits
Someone reports me that actually is impossible to get the damage shown in this image:
(This report is before the last RENEWAL update from malufett, but...)
it is correct however def reduction is different it doesn't used the percentage reduction..anyway I'll just add it after I add/discover all skill that do the same reduction...So, iRO wiki is wrong?
http://irowiki.org/classic/Throw_Kunai (pre-re) vs http://irowiki.org/wiki/Throw_Kunai (re)
300% vs 300% ATKx3 hits
OMFG. A Ninja user reports me that throw kunai damage has increased from ~400 damage to ~12K damage!!!
oopss..a typo in db it should be not increasing damage..OMFG. A Ninja user reports me that throw kunai damage has increased from ~400 damage to ~12K damage!!!
524,9,8,1,-1,0x40,0,5,3,no,0,0,0,weapon,0, NJ_KUNAI,Throw Kunaishould be
524,9,8,1,-1,0x40,0,5,-3,no,0,0,0,weapon,0, NJ_KUNAI,Throw Kunai
Fixed @ 83e3b8d22acc73aeaafbf2a95e1fb9e6b228a63a
